Mets Rally From 5% Win Odds to Beat Yankees in Extras

With two outs in the ninth inning and their win probability at just 5%, the New York Mets pulled off the kind of magic that seemed impossible.

Tyrone Taylor hooked a game-tying three-run homer around the left-field foul pole to breathe life back into Citi Field. An inning later, Carson Benge hit a walk-off fielder's choice that sent the entire dugout spilling onto the field in celebration.

The 7-6 victory over the Yankees on Sunday ended a stunning 96-game losing streak for the Mets when trailing after eight innings. The last time they'd won in that situation was Pete Alonso's legendary blast in the 2024 Wild Card Series, a moment still etched in franchise history.

"Awesome," Taylor said afterward. "That's all I can say is awesome."

The game looked bleak for most of the afternoon. A dropped popup in the sixth inning sparked a four-run Yankees rally, and starter Freddy Peralta struggled again to find his rhythm.

But something shifted. Luis Torrens delivered a pinch-hit two-run double to chip away at the deficit. Reliever Sean Manaea, a seldom-used long man, steadied the ship by retiring six of his final seven batters.

Then came the ninth-inning heroics that had the ballpark shaking.

Why This Inspires

This wasn't just about baseball statistics or rivalry bragging rights. The Mets entered this series battered and hurting, both physically and emotionally.

They'd lost star closer Clay Holmes to a broken fibula on Friday night. They're missing multiple key players to injuries and have openly discussed the emotional toll the season has taken.

Manager Carlos Mendoza has watched his team struggle through rough stretches, searching for moments that could spark belief. "We know that we've got to start playing better," he said. "But that's in the past."

This comeback offered exactly what the clubhouse needed. Not just a win, but proof that even without their best lineup, even when facing near-impossible odds, they could find a way.

Taking two of three games from the Yankees bought them time for injured players to heal and gave them something more valuable than standings points: confidence.

When you refuse to quit at 5%, you remember what's possible at any percentage.